\documentstyle[12pt]{article} \begin{document} \begin{center} \bf{{\Large A Numerical Methodology for Reducing Total Simulation Error }} \end{center} \begin{center} A. Louise Perkins \\ Naval Research Laboratory \\ Peter A. Orlin \\ Planning Systems Incorporated \\ Lucy F. Smedstad \\ Naval Research Laboratory \\ \end{center} \begin{abstract} For more than three decades we have known that higher order accurate schemes for evolution equations can be disappointing in practice. This can be partly explained by analyzing the types of error present. Realistically initialized formally time accurate studies, based on reducing the numerical truncation error only, may be misleading. The physically-based mathematical approximations, used to construct the governing equations for the simulation, may fail to adequately model long time dynamics. Order of magnitude estimates of physical parameters in the governing equations may even lead to failure in short time. This is because formal accuracy may be nullified by the small errors in the mathematical formulation of the equation. The Taylor Series-based numerical approximations, when used with realistic (data-based) initial conditions, lose convergence. As the numerical grid approaches a continuum, the error bars on data remain the same. Hence the derivatives of data values taken closer and closer together approximate instrumental noise, not physics. Also, the details of the simulation configuration may introduce errors. Taken together, the above family of errors lead us to conclude that preparing a realistic model simulation should consider some measure of the total simulation error, rather than just focus on formal order of numerical truncation error. Towards this end, we define a total simulation error measure, and discuss how it more accurately tracks the performance of a realistic simulation (this is essentially what is already done in numerical weather prediction). We then show an example of a numerical approximation that has been designed to reduce total simulation error, and discuss the methodology used in the design. \end{abstract} \end{document}